Posted by
J. Bradford Sivils on Thursday, September 10, 2009 4:00:00 PM
Thank goodness for Rush Limbaugh! On his show yesterday, a woman caller described how her primary care physician referred her to a radiology center for an X-Ray. Once there, she had the "audacity" (remember that word?) to ask what the X-ray would cost. She was told it would cost $269.00 (give or take). Rush's caller thought that was outrageous, so she went home and made a few phone calls and found a radiologist that would take the X-ray for $20.00!! So much for the high cost of health care! Darn that free market, anyway!
In one of the 2008 Presidential debates between Barack Obama and John McCain, Brian Williams (I believe) asked the question, "Is health care a right? A privilege? Or a responsibility?" The candidates gave their meandering responses which we had heard before. But neither challenged the validity of the question!
Of course I have a right to health care! If I have a splinter in my finger or a blister on my foot, I can walk into any doctor's office, slap $20.00 on their counter and ask, "Can you fix me up for $20.00?" If they tell me, "No, we can't do it for that little money.", I can go to the doctor's office down the hall or up the street and find someone who will treat my problem for $20.00! Sure, I'll pay more for a broken arm or leg. But I'll find someone to treat me for those injuries as well.
The real question that Brian Williams should have been asking is, "Do Americans have the right to free money from the Government to attend to their medical needs?" Because that's what the issue really is!
Whether a "Single Payer" Government plan or private insurance company, when presented with a bill for medical care, more often than not the bill is or will be paid. Regardless of the price! I spent a year on disablity due to a back injury. I had chiropractic care. Chiropractors would have tiered pricing. If I paid myself, the price was lower than if they billed to an insurance company. If the insurance company pays the bill for my treatment without questioning the charge, there is no incentive for the doctor/chiropractor to lower the price!
The entitlement mindset in America has grown like a malignant cancer on society. Americans now feel that health care insurance offered by employers is their personal property and they have the right to it. And then Americans get chagrined when employers cut back on insurance coverage or employees lose their jobs and insurance coverage at the same time. And yet, if Americans were responsible for the own health care expenditures and shopped for good prices and good service, prices would come down! The Free Market would respond to demands!
And, no, Americans do not have a right to "free money". For health care, food, homes, cars, gasoline or any other of their needs. My "Single Payer Plan" is me! I have a right to go anywhere I want to ask for medical treatment. If refused, I go somewhere else. It is my responsibility to pay for it. It is no one else's responsibility. And I'll get treatment for less money than a government plan will pay.